Well, I have worked at companies that offered it. I even bought the extra coverage at 1 of them.
Here are my thoughts, of course they are due to my life experiences.
TO ME, it seemed like another insurance scam. Fact of the matter is .... most of us working slaves are so busy working that we seldom get hurt or injured. Even if we do... it is for a short term ... because most of us have to get back to work. Most companies short term comp insurance covers 80% ( approx ) of our wages and for most folks... the issue is not the loss of partial income , it is the gap , the inbetween when no payroll check is coming & the short term disability checks arrive.
What happens is .... I ended up paying extra to AFLAC for an expected income shortcoming that never happened. I had my appendix out , and busted up my ribs bailing out on a sled ( IN the last 12 years ). Neither were during my AFLAC coverage and when I had it, I forgot about it and paid them for years... Alot of potential for them to earn.... but IMO most worker bee's like myself seldom use that type of insurance.
Maybe it's me ( I'm Just lucky ) or maybe it's my SUPER POWERFULL Guardian Angle.... but I have cheated death many times...
I would go with the ( 2nd ) since I'm lucky at some things and not others...
I believe that it is money that can be spent on something more useful.