I talked to my dealer about this when I bought my 09 RMK 800. The plug should be apart if you use anything but NON-OXYGENATED fuel. In Minnesota, everything at a regular gas pump has ethanol in it, so it's oxygenated. You'd have to get it special from somewhere. I don't know what other states do for use of ethanol, but in MN, any regular pump, whether 92 premium or 87 regular unleaded, it needs to stay unplugged. In fact, they told me not to bother paying the higher price for 92, the 87 gives me the same result without hurting the engine.
I'd think if you have any oxygenated fuel in the tank, you should leave it unplugged. So if you want to use the good stuff, make sure to use up what's in there first.