This is a topic that gets revisited every year, but I'm happy to report my experience. Obviously, there are pros and cons to both setups. However, for me it just came down to reliability. It seemed like every other year I was replacing a $90 electric visor. I switched to goggles about 5 years ago, and I'll never go back to an electric shield. It doesn't really matter what kind of goggles you use, most will get a good seal, you just have move it around for a second and make sure it's seated. I find the most important component is the mask, if you wear a Klim mask you cant go wrong. I usually wear the lighter one, but if it gets really cold, I'll wear the heavier one. Last, if you want the best of both worlds, get a set of heated goggles (very handy in freezing mist). My only complaint about goggles is the peripheral vision is not as good, and it can be a little noisier, but I'm on a four stroke so that's a non-factor. I usually carry three goggles in my trunk bag, one for bright sunlight, one for darkness or flat light, and the electric for the funky stuff.
