I've been at most of these so here's my (2) cents:
-Timbers-Worst night sleep ever on a 20 year old futon. Felt like stuffed with bowling balls. The bed was nice, if you go, make sure everyone has a bed, if you let your bussies use the pull out/futon, you will hear about it.-Located top of the lake, sort of near Bergland Bay Bar and Hoop.
-Walleye Lodge-Closer to Bergland Bay Bar, cleaner place, no complaints.
-Root Cellar-didn't have any issues with Rick, have heard plenty of stories though. His place is new and clean, plus good food/bar on property.
-Gogebic Lodge, Great bar, good food, staying in one of the cabins, can advise later on that after next week.
Depends on your budget. If you want nicer and don't need to be in walking distance to a bar/rest then I would look into renting a house/cabin. If you're on a budget, look into the 3 above. Any other questions, let us know.