I've had a John Deere Z425 for about 9 years now. It has always left lines in the lawn,from new. I'm diligent about maintenance. The deck gets cleaned after every mow, up on car ramps and scraped clean. Great machine, but not great at leaving a perfect lawn. Early this summer it developed a pretty good leak on the left side transmission. Without time to fix over the summer, I bought a new mower. Fixing the John Deere will be a winter project, when I have more time. I bought a similar size Toro . Only difference is a little bigger engine and a fab deck, instead of stamped on the JD. The Toro does a much better job with actually mowing the lawn. No stripes anywhere. I think the JD machine is better as a whole, but not if you want a perfect lawn. Still trying to get it to where I like it. But, for now, the Toro way out performs the JD with leaving a well manicured lawn.