I guess I would start by load testing the battery as stated above first, then check voltage coming from the key. Next check voltage across the solenoid from battery and also to the starter and make sure it is working correctly.
I also had the first battery charging all summer long but on a smart charger, seemed it cooked the battery. The next season I bought another battery tender and when I put the battery back in the sled about a month ago it fired right up, maybe the same thing happened to yours. Just a thought.
You can also test the starter to make sure that’s not the issue as well, not may parts that can cause the issue, a little patience and testing will reveal the problem. You have to have 12 volts from the key, the solenoid has to be working correctly and the starter has to work as well then as long as the battery is good it should start.
A lot of very smart people on the board that I’m sure will chime in soon on how to go about all the testing, I can do it but I’m not very good at explaining how to do it. Good luck and keep us informed.