Ya, I got the same "too bad, so sad" from American Family last spring. They've had our coverage for 20+ years for home, vehicles, boat, and sled. Every year our premiums increased without one claim, ever. So I did some comparison shopping, one local Farmer's agent didn't even return my call, guess we can scratch him from the list. What I found is that they were all pretty close, some were even higher than my current coverage, except one. State Farm saved me about a hundred dollars a year for the snowmobile. I know there's a lot of factors like location, credit score and claims but it pays to spend some time comparing companies and agents for no other reason than peace of mind.
My annual premium for the machine was 242 with American Family, State Farm came in at 140 a year with a $500 Deductible. Collision and Liability Limits are 300K on a Ski Doo 1200 4 Stroke. There's still some companies out there that base their premiums on C.C.'s verses Horsepower. When they see those larger C.C.'s their eyes roll back in their heads replaced with Dollar Signs.
It looks like costs are going up for everyone, there's always an exception but for the most part they're passing the expenses on to everyone regardless of your claims history.