I will disagree about wide/narrow tires
the wider tires help in backing up in snow and not trenching as much, that's the reason the OEM maker's use them on snowmobile trailers
and I agree about the load rating is the bigger issue here,
I personally prefer to run the highest load rating I can get(tend to be more plys, and less flats in my experience)
but also keep an eye on speed ratings, as when your trucks tries are going 75, smaller trailer tires are going a LOT faster, and heat build up
MY 2 place has 18.5x8.5x8 and all are bias ply tires I can get, and at 80 mph I have had several come apart on me over the 25 yrs or so I have this trailer(and never fun there LOL) but I replace mine after a few yrs or when they get to about 50% tread as well, as better safe than sorry in my book, changing tires on the side of a HWY SUCKS!
I NOW limit things to about 73 mph
and have YET to have another blow out since doing so!!
I'll add two more tips here,
in off season jack trailer up and get tires off the ground, prevents flat spots from sitting long
and buy and carry a good portable impact wrench, IF you get a flat it will save you a TON of time on the road side!