coldsmokejr
New member
My comment wasn't aimed at the gentleman with 4K in repairs, it was aimed directly at you for FN up another thread. Sorry to the poster for interrupting this thread, but, yes its just getting old.
My comment wasn't aimed at the gentleman with 4K in repairs, it was aimed directly at you for FN up another thread. Sorry to the poster for interrupting this thread, but, yes its just getting old.
Hoosier,
We've got both a Honda Odyssey and a Ford Expedition. To compare:
Minivan
- More interior room for stuff. The floor to ceiling space is much larger so you can haul a lot more stuff in the vehicle.
- Easier to get in/out, especially with kids and car seats
- Better, but not great, gas mileage
- "uncool"
- Moderate winter weather capability. (Work pretty well as long as you have decent tires and take it easy but not as good as an SUV. We have driven minivans to northern MN many times without major problems.)
- Moderate towing capability. I wouldn't tow more than a two place with one, and the Chryslers and some Hondas have known tranny concerns.
SUV
- Less interior room for stuff
- Poor gas mileage
- Great towing capability
- Great winter weather capability
- More challenging with kids/car seats. Harder to get around in the vehicle with the seats. More areas for "stuff" to fall out of reach. (Dropped toys, dropped food, etc.)
- More comfortable for a "full house" of passengers. (8 adults can comfortably ride in my Expedition, six adults comfortably in the van.)
- Drivers seat/position more comfortable for me (6'3") than any minvan I've driven
- Easier to park and maneuver
SUV is my daily driver and van is hers. I prefer driving the SUV, but am OK with the van. My wife is happy to drive either. She's really attached to her Odyssey (165k and she still won't talk about getting another one.) In fair weather and day to day the van is easier for the family hauler. In bad weather, towing the trailer, and for comfort I prefer the SUV. Even though mileage isn't great in the van it is still ~50% better than the truck so we tend to take the van for daily driving. We are an active scouting family so I use the SUV as a truck a lot in addition to towing the sleds. Towing trailers, going off road, etc. I’m towing the troop trailer to Virginia on Friday to hike on the Appalachian Trail.
Bottom line: We really like both. If the vehicle is for your wife as a daily driver with the young kids and you won’t need it for towing much I’d go with the van. If you will use it for towing the sleds then I’d go with the SUV, but know you will need a car top carrier and/or hitch rack for those vacations with the kids.
I’d also seriously suggest checking out the Expedition. I’ve had great luck with mine and can’t complain about anything but the gas mileage (which all of the large SUV’s suffer from.) I don’t know anyone who doesn’t love theirs. Look for the EL model if you can find one for more cargo space.
No problem. Yeah, mainly trying to get input from those who have owned similar vehicles and have ownership experiences to share.
My comment wasn't aimed at the gentleman with 4K in repairs, it was aimed directly at you for FN up another thread. Sorry to the poster for interrupting this thread, but, yes its just getting old.