An unknown? That is totally not true. He is completely known! Your second and third assumptions are correct......post surgery play and age 36. But from the tapes of him throwing practice routes at Duke University I think the question of "can he still throw the rock"? are answered. Now it is ust a question of finding the team that he fits into nicely and vica versa.
Bottom line: he'll be an elite QB again as long as his health i.e. his current neck injury, hold up under all the duress a NFL QB withstands.
Not too mention did you see the list of players released by the Colts since yesterday? The list is longer than my arm, and they aren't second stringers. Joseph Addai, Gary Brackett, Dallas Clark, Curtis Painter, Melvin Bullitt plus the ones they have on free agency: Reggie Wayne-Peytons favorite target, Pierre Garcon-1000yds receiving and prob better than Wayne in the long run,
Jeff Saturday, LONG TIME CENTER TO PM, and seven more that include a 11 year veteran to the offensive line and current right guard not too mention Jacob Tamme who was the most productive tight end in the second half of the NFL season . Peyton would have had no more of his go-to-guys left and that spells trouble for your offense.
Irsay is cleaning house just like he said he was going to do. He started with the head coach six weeks ago and he is cleaning the board. Everyone thought he was blowing smoke so he could feel better about letting PM go but now he is proving his point. Either out of spite to prove the sports pundits wrong or because it is what he originally intended to do. Either way it is not a bad direction that the Colts are headed into. And in my opinion, I would take RG3 over Luck. My .02¢
______________________________
View attachment 31988