Yamahauler: I would recommend it. My husband is a huge gamer and he isn't all that impressed but he plays Halo, Modern Warfare, Forza etc. I enjoy the Kinect for what it is, mindeless fun. It certainly is not for serious gaming but for family, friends fun I love it.
The just using your body is better than the Wii, nothing to hold and it logs you in by sensing your body, it can tell the difference between my husband and I. We have the Kinect Adventures, the Kinect Sports and Joy Ride. I mostly do the Kinect sports. Ping Pong, Volley Ball, Boxing, Bowling Etc. My body hurt for 2 days! Also there are some workout ones but I have heard they aren't all that good yet.