I didn't actually order from Babbitts because I found a slightly better price and a better shipping option for me from partspitstop.com out of Grand Rapids. However, I called Babbitts before I posted earlier and they confirmed that the lower price was correct. And I went all the way through the ordering process except for confirming it (the last step), so I believe the new price is correct. So it sounds like we're getting conflicting info.
Another site I checked had it near $200, so my opinion is that Polaris just dropped the price on this part. Below is the info copied directly from my order confirmation email from partspitstop.com:
1 of 2203794 - SUBSTITUTED BY 2203794 (4011440) @ $70.75ea.
Subtotal: $70.75
If I were you, I'd probably push a little harder on Babbitts or call your credit card company. I hope I ordered the correct part. I know that the price was higher at Babbitts yesterday.