momoney2123
New member
There were two off sides whistled dead and both time they were talking about unabated to the quarterback, but neither seemed to be the case. I'm sure someone can provide better insight on this than me, but I always thought the play continued if just the defense was offsides and the ball had to be snapped when they were offsides for that call to be made. Then a couple years ago they changed the rule to be if the defender jumping made the offensive lineman flinch or move, the play was whistled dead and the penalty was still called on the defense. What I've noticed a lot now is once the defender jumps, the O-lineman moves and points to the defender as if to say "you jumped and that caused me to move". I believe that is what causes the play to get whistled dead. If the O-line doesn't move and the ball is snapped while the defender is offsides it becomes a free play.
Maybe I'm wrong on that, but the way I see it is that the O-line guys are actually the ones causing the plays to get whistled dead in their hast to make sure the ref's see the defender moving
To my understanding unabated to the QB is a judgement call that if the ref feels the QB is in danger of being hit blows the whistle and stops the play, its simply to keep the stars safe. When in doubt the ref will always blow the whistle especially on QBs like rodgers, brady, manning as they dont want to be the ref that didnt blow the whistle and got one of these guys hurt. The refs are not only payed to officiate the game but keep players safe..especially the star QBs. If the ref didnt blow the whistle and rodgers got his A s s lit up and got hurt, these same fans would then blame the ref for getting their QB hurt. Darned if you do, darned if you dont.