Everyone has their own idea of a perfect trip. Someone might want to sit at the base of a hill and high mark all day, others might want to carve up every meadow they can find, and others like to play in the trees/deep snow.
I have ridden out west several times and never had a guide; always having a blast. I hear good and bad about having a guide and plan to try it out this year. I spoke with Carter on the phone for 45 minutes over the weekend and he sold me on giving it a shot. I do think every guide is different and that you can have a bad experience with a guide. I also think that if everyone in your group isn't at the same level you won't have as good of an experience. Having never had one I might not know what I’m missing. Each person in our group has a GPS so getting deep into the back country isn’t that bad. I wouldn’t suggest going out on your own without one.
Saying all of this, our trip to Togwotee this year and not staying at the lodge is based on people's budget. I think I'll be able to spend half of what I would if I stay at TML. Don't get me wrong, I'm all for it and want to but the rest of my group doesn't and I need to go with majority. I’m getting married next year and need to be sensible LOL.
The trip is what you make it, the group ride with, etc. I'm sure you'll have a blast riding out west no matter where you go or who you're with. I love riding the UP and once heard a guy said he'd never ride the UP after going west. I thought he was nuts but can understand his logic now. I will still ride the UP LOL.
One thing no one has mentioned here are beacons and probes. If anyone is going out for the first time I highly suggest you have them (rent or own) and know how to use them. If you can't get to Mike Duffy's Avy course (Madison and Green Bay) this year I suggest reading as much as you can online and watching videos on Youtube. I saw a video on youtube that really scared me last year. A hill I wouldn't hesitate to play on slid and buried two guys. Granted you shouldn't have two on a hill.... but the fact it slid is what got me. Avalanche prone hills or danger is something that a guide would be a huge help with. My first trip west was to Cooke and I rode with guys who knew this stuff. If it is your first time west you might want to seriously consider a guide for the first few days.
Whatever anyone decides to do will be a blast. Be safe and come back to JD’s site and post pics for us.