2 Stroke E-Tek vs. 4-Tek or 4S Yam

F

fusion

Guest
Time to formulate a decision for next year regarding new sled. After much consideration I've about 95% decided to go back to a 2-Stroke for one of my sleds. The only thing I would consider would be an E-Tek. It's not that I don't like the 4-strokes. But a couple of things about them are really bothersome.
1.) Weight - although you don't feel it on the trail, when you have to pick these things up to get them on dollies to move in/out of garage, or pull or pick them up to get them on a trailer - WOW - backache. As much as you try, invariably you end up moving these things around on your own and they are a killer. But that alone wouldn't make me change.
2.) Oil changes - I'd love to hear feedback on this one. First of all, it sounds too complicated for me to do on my own. I know most of you are mechanically orented and this might not be intimidating, but for a guy like me, when it comes to basic disassembly and reconnecting things like air boxes and head-light pods, I go into anxiety attach mode. I normally wind up PO'd at some point, and the frustation isn't worth the time and effort. So what do I do? Take it to a dealer. I used a dealer for the Vector in the fall that saved me a bit, even though they quoted less, it still cost me approx. $105. The Apex was done this past weekend to the tune of $160 - at an authorized dealer. To me, this is just crazy for an oil change.

I could buy 4 gd gallons of oil for $160 and just ride an E-Tek for 5 years. Not to mention I'm never inconveniced with having to take my sled in for an oil change. For a guy like me that rides 500 - 1000 miles a year, I think a 2-stroke makes more sense. These E-Tek 600's go about 420 lbs., compared to the dry weight apex/vector at 575 - 590. That's a big difference.

The other two factors you have to consider are:
1.) Resale - the 4-stroke probably holds value a bit better than a 2, but if you trade or move to a 2 yr. newer model every other year, is the difference significant? Seems to me, the 4-stroke might make sense if you are keeping them for 4+ years.
2.) Quality: Yamaha 4-stroke quality vs. BRP 2-stroke. Don't know how to quantify this, but I'm looking for opinions. So far, other than a minor adjustment to the reverse mechanism on the Apex, I haven't had any warranty claims or any problems, other than lousy hand warmers, fixed with a $150 mod and 1 hr. labor. Looking back several years, I owned a few Doo's in the 90's, and many Poo's, with no warranty problems and no burndowns. For the way I ride, I don't see a difference, but again, looking for any/all comments.

One more thing - does anyone have feedback on the 4-Tek and if it's easier or possible to do an oil change on your own? How does oil change on 4-Tek compare to 4S Yamaha?
TIA
 

indy_500

Well-known member
4 stroke. Never EVER will have to worry about the engine going kaput. All 4 brands 4 strokes are pretty good with yami at the top. There's a thread going on right now about etecs blowing up. polaris cfi blow up. "clean running" 2 stroke is just not possible. too lean and runs too hot.
 

ridindirty800

Active member
I have 2010 4-tec ski doo renagade x. The oil change on these is not bad. Take the exhaust off which is a few springs and then remove a little shield and u are right at ur filter. There is a drain plug right in the bottom of the belly pan to drain the oil. Its not a bad job at all. The sled rides great has awesome power for corner to corner. Ill take this sled anyday over my old 800 rev stroker. If I were u I would go to dootalk.com and look in the xr forum section. Many questions about the 4-tec vs 2 stroke. Lots of info on both. Not sure how u ride but the ski doo 600 ace 4 stroke is getting good reviews but its not made to be a fast top end sled. Rumers about a 800 ace coming out and we will find out tomorrow when ski doo releases the 2012's. Any question on the 4 tec let me know glad to help out.
 
F

fusion

Guest
Ridindirty....thanks for the response. How long do you estimate it takes you to do an oil change, with filter, taking your time?

And what type of oil do you typically use?

I presume you use BRP filters, and not after-market?

Any special tools you need or is everything accessible with standard sockets/extensions?

I have been considering a 4-Tek as well, and if oil change is doable I may just have my next sled - in a Renegade to get the longer track.
 

ridindirty800

Active member
Ridindirty....thanks for the response. How long do you estimate it takes you to do an oil change, with filter, taking your time?

And what type of oil do you typically use?

I presume you use BRP filters, and not after-market?

Any special tools you need or is everything accessible with standard sockets/extensions?

I have been considering a 4-Tek as well, and if oil change is doable I may just have my next sled - in a Renegade to get the longer track.



Oil type- You can use any 0W-40 Full Synthetic that you want. Brp has there own, Amsoil the lists goes on. I have used Brp Oil so far and there filter as the engine is still under warranty till 2012!

As far as tools you just need a spring tool to remove the exhaust and a Torx 40 head to remove the oil drain plug. You can get a torx 40 for a few bucks at any tool store. There is just a oil filter cover you need to remove to take the filter off but its easy to get at and any standard tools will do the job. If you take your time its prob about an hour job or so. The hardest part is a little bit of oil will drain into the belly pen when you remove the plug and if you dont do a good job cleaning it up it will leake a small amount of oil under the sled for a while till its all out. I just get a can of brake cleaner and spray the belly pan out really good and wipe what I can with a rag.

Here is a forum on the oil changes on dootalk you can read if you want some good info! http://www.dootalk.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=412507
 

snow_monkey

New member
I went through all the brain damage that you are trying to decide what to do. I spent tons of time doing research talking to previous owners and reading every article I could get my hands on. Although the track record of 4 strokes must not be denied the one issue that kept popping up in all the reviews was weight and rider fatigue at the end of the day. For the average trailrider these are non issues and the four stroke ticket works for a number of riding styles. I have had the 600 e-tech for this entire season and I only have good things to say. The sled is light, uses very little fuel and oil, and has great throttle response. I picked it out of a drift last week and tossed it back on to the trail the weight difference is amazing. The xp platform makes you a driver not just a rider. You become very active once you become comfortable with the riding position and it is a blast.
 

Banks93

New member
I have the new 2011 Apex XTX and 2010 Vector LTX GT and once you go 4 stroke I don't think you want to go back. If I didn't have the Apex my next choice would be the 1200 4-tec Renegade which is very similiar to a Vector with a little more rider forward seating position.

The 800 E-tec is a fast light sled but you will never get the durability out of the engine that you get with the 4 strokes. The EPS makes the sled feel lighter. It even made the 600 E-tec feel like heavy steering and that is about as light as you can get.

Buy the time you are done buying slides, boogie wheels, new skis and carbides you might have an engine rebuild paid for to get a 800 E-tec. I would say it all depends on how you ride. If you like light sleds go 2 stroke and if you trail ride go 1200 4-tec, Apex or Vector LTX GT(FI).
 

ridindirty800

Active member
I went through all the brain damage that you are trying to decide what to do. I spent tons of time doing research talking to previous owners and reading every article I could get my hands on. Although the track record of 4 strokes must not be denied the one issue that kept popping up in all the reviews was weight and rider fatigue at the end of the day. For the average trailrider these are non issues and the four stroke ticket works for a number of riding styles. I have had the 600 e-tech for this entire season and I only have good things to say. The sled is light, uses very little fuel and oil, and has great throttle response. I picked it out of a drift last week and tossed it back on to the trail the weight difference is amazing. The xp platform makes you a driver not just a rider. You become very active once you become comfortable with the riding position and it is a blast.

I hear more about weight being an issue in the cat,polaris, and yami 4 strokes! Ski Doo has the lightest for stroke! Once you play with the set up and get it dialed in I dont see how a 4-tec will wear you out! This thing handles better than my 800 Rev did. Now to move it around the garage ok its heaiver up front then the others, but on trails I dont think so!

Here are some comparison numbers

Ski Doo 1200 - 517 lbs
Ski Doo 600 etec- 450 lbs
Ski Doo 800 etec- 489 lbs
Cat z1 LXR- from what I could find about 640 lbs
Yami Apex- 575 lbs

Here is some other feed back if the weight is your concern! http://www.dootalk.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=309763
 
Last edited:
F

fusion

Guest
Sled picks

Banks....I like all 3 sleds you listed in the last sentence of your post. Add in the 600 E-Tek and my next sled purchase will for sure be one of these 4. But to narrow it down further, and for something different, it will probably be either the 4-Tek or 600 E-Tek. I want to have the Doo and keep one 4S Yam so I can ride them for a season and compare. I'll be keeping either the Vector GT or the Apex LTX GT, not sure which at this point.

I'd be willing to bet I can buy a 2011 Apex Std. (128") for about 10 G's even, about July/Aug time frame.
 

gary_in_neenah

Super Moderator
Staff member
Depending on the weather, I'm near the end of my first full season on the 1200 4 tec. It's been a great ride and I've had no issues this season. I'm actually looking forward to the first Oil Change as a learning opportunity. My mileage has been in the 15 miles per gallon range, all trail riding with incredible torque and she stays flat in the corners. The engine is very quiet and very clean, at high speeds all you hear is the wind. I was concerned about the weight also but it hasn't been an issue and actually seems to help with better cornering.

Not much for storage but then I don't have a need to carry that much. No plugs, no oil, etc. The spare belt and tow strap fit in the nose and I did add a Dash Bag for the small stuff.

I've said this before, the 1200 4 tec could be the last machine that I ever buy, it's that good!
 
F

fusion

Guest
Yeah, I agree, my complaint has never been being worn out after riding all day, with regard to the Vector, or the Apex. It's just the moving them on/off trailer if you have to, or getting the slugs on the shop dollies into the garage. (Without ripping up my garage floor - yes I know, gotta be difficult)

4-Tek shorty (121) is 499lbs. That's roughly the same weight as my old 2003 xc600sp. I can live with that kind of weight. Thats still 100 lbs. less than the Apex.
 

Banks93

New member
Banks....I like all 3 sleds you listed in the last sentence of your post. Add in the 600 E-Tek and my next sled purchase will for sure be one of these 4. But to narrow it down further, and for something different, it will probably be either the 4-Tek or 600 E-Tek. I want to have the Doo and keep one 4S Yam so I can ride them for a season and compare. I'll be keeping either the Vector GT or the Apex LTX GT, not sure which at this point.

I'd be willing to bet I can buy a 2011 Apex Std. (128") for about 10 G's even, about July/Aug time frame.

I would say yes close to that amount is probably correct. If you like speed go with the 800 over the 600. If you like gas savings and oil savings go with the 600. That is the two differences. I would keep the Apex LTX GT. The long track Renegade is what you want if you are going ski doo. The 1200 really is very similar to the 2010 Vector with the FI but the rider foward seating is better on the ski doo.
 

Banks93

New member
Yeah, I agree, my complaint has never been being worn out after riding all day, with regard to the Vector, or the Apex. It's just the moving them on/off trailer if you have to, or getting the slugs on the shop dollies into the garage. (Without ripping up my garage floor - yes I know, gotta be difficult)

4-Tek shorty (121) is 499lbs. That's roughly the same weight as my old 2003 xc600sp. I can live with that kind of weight. Thats still 100 lbs. less than the Apex.

Get the rouski wheels and put some horse mats down on the floor. You will miss the power of the Apex and the thing I like about the new Apex is it is a smoother powerband then the older Apex. It doesn't jerk you off when you pin it and it doesn't pull you forward on the engine breaking. If they could just fix the skis, carbides and hyfax issue I would be in heaven.
 

snow_monkey

New member
I hear more about weight being an issue in the cat,polaris, and yami 4 strokes! Ski Doo has the lightest for stroke! Once you play with the set up and get it dialed in I dont see how a 4-tec will wear you out! This thing handles better than my 800 Rev did. Now to move it around the garage ok its heaiver up front then the others, but on trails I dont think so!

Here are some comparison numbers

Ski Doo 1200 - 517 lbs
Ski Doo 600 etec- 450 lbs
Ski Doo 800 etec- 489 lbs
Cat z1 LXR- from what I could find about 640 lbs
Yami Apex- 575 lbs

Here is some other feed back if the weight is your concern! http://www.dootalk.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=309763

The arcticle was based on four stroke vs two stroke using the earlier nytro as a comparison.
 

whitedust

Well-known member
I just bought a new 150 Etek outboard for the same reason I just don't want to change oil & filter or want the long distance Truck towing weight of Yamaha 4s outboard + the Yamaha 4s outboard would have been $2K more. Both are excellent but went with the Etek in outboards. On the other hand I don't think I will ever go back to any brand 2s sled just have had too many engine burndowns & left me walking on the trail tooooooooo many times. I also don't want to turn my sleds over every couple of years, I see that as a PIA, so big miles make better sense to me on Yamaha 4s. If you do turn sleds every 2 years with 2,000 miles any brand 2s will do. On the other hand I would wait to see what 2012 brings on the 4s side all brands as best of both worlds might emerge don't know until we see them all.
 
1200 skidoo renegade

I completely agree with gary! Been a polaris and skidoo guy and by far this is the best sled ive ever owned hands down! Ive heard mixed reviews about the etecs and am glad i went 4 tec.
 
Top